The Person Who Buys Your Product Isn't Always the Person Who Uses It

When Packaged Facts asked pet owners why they had switched foods, 30% of dog owners and 40% of cat owners said their pet had stopped liking or eating its food [1]. In those cases, the person who paid didn't decide to leave. The pet did, and the owner followed.
And it's not only pets. For a lot of consumer products, the person using it isn't the person who bought it. Think of that person as your second customer. The experience after the sale is where the second customer decides whether your product gets bought again, and often nobody on your team owns it.
The person who decides may never show up in your program
The second customer is the kid eating the snacks, the partner using the razor, the parent taking the vitamins, and the dog at the food bowl. They may never see your checkout page, and your loyalty program may never see them either.
A program built only around the buyer would see those pet food purchases stop, but it may not know why. It keeps a record of who made the purchase. But with pets, and with a lot of other consumer products, you may never understand why that call was made in the first place.
This is something you need to consider before you reach for a bigger offer, because more points for the buyer probably won't fix a problem the buyer didn't cause.
Feeling known only works if the brand knows who's there
Bond Brand Loyalty's 2025 U.S. research found that the two biggest reasons people stay loyal to a program are special access and feeling known. In their study, both of those rank ahead of financial rewards. Members who said their offers felt relevant were 4.3 times as likely to say they're loyal to the program [2]. But a brand can't make someone feel known if it doesn't know they're there.
Some brands have made room for the second customer without changing who pays. LEGO lets a parent verify their own account once and then link their child's account to it, so the child can share what they build and get a more personal experience with the parent's OK [3]. PetSmart sends rewards members a gift during their pet's birthday month, once they add that date to their account [4]. The buyer still pays and still earns value, but now the second customer has a reason to stay connected, and the brand learns who it's actually serving.
Someone needs to own the experience after the sale
A customer journey map is a brand's plan for every step a customer goes through. Gartner found that 31% of those maps stop at the sale or the delivery, and that brands whose customer experience programs beat expectations were 2.3 times more likely to plan past that point [5]. So on nearly a third of those maps, the second customer never shows up at all.
Customers notice when nobody owns the experience after the sale. Diane Meyer, who worked at Weber and De'Longhi, shared a Weber customer's comment that "the site makes it seem like once you sell it, you don't care" [6]. That customer was looking for parts and service information after the sale, and nobody was there to help.
I've seen how that happens from the inside. When I ran loyalty at a consumer brand, I sat between customer service, marketing, ecommerce, IT, operations, and the store teams. Every one of them touched the customer after the sale. You can have that many teams involved, but it's hard to create a good customer experience when no one is responsible for it, and the team who should own it keeps getting pulled into other work.
And unlike an app or a service people use every day, many consumer products are bought once and then used for weeks or months, sometimes by someone other than the buyer. That stretch needs an owner whose job is to think about the second customer as much as the first.
So pick one product and ask your team two questions. Who actually uses it, and who on your team is responsible for that person after the last mile or after they leave the store? If the answers are "we're not sure" and "no one," you've found where the work begins. From there, give the second customer a way in, like a profile of their own on the buyer's account, a place to leave a review, or a reason to share what they love about the product. To see whether that work pays off, use the approach I laid out in How to Prove Your Loyalty Program Is Working.
The dog will never fill out a survey, but the kids, partners, and parents using your products will tell you plenty if someone on your team is there to listen.
See how TrueLoyal helps consumer brands build loyalty with the people who buy their products and the people who use them.
Sources
- Packaged Facts survey of pet owners, 2020, via Petfood Industry
- Bond Brand Loyalty, In a World Obsessed With Value, Knowing Your Customer Still Wins, May 2026, citing The Loyalty Report 2025 USA
- LEGO, Verified Parental Consent
- PetSmart, Treats Rewards Birthday and Gotcha Day Gift
- Gartner, May 2022
- Diane Meyer, HER-ON Atlas #26: The Retention Paradox, LinkedIn, Aug 2025













