Your Holiday Gift Recipients Might Be Customers You've Never Met

When I was at a food delivery brand, we added a simple option at checkout so people could tell us an order was a gift. That small checkbox ended up changing what we sold.
Over time, it showed us that givers often don't know what the person receiving the gift really wants. Every recipient is a second customer, like the ones I wrote about in my last post, and this time of year you'll have more of them than usual. The first week after a gift arrives is when you can learn who they are, as long as you give them a reason to tell you.
Gift bundles assumed the giver knew best
Combined with our targeting data, surveys, and customer panels, the gift option showed us patterns. We could tell a corporate gift from one going to family or friends in another state, though not who those people were to the buyer.
We offered gift bundles, but they were limiting. The more we learned, the clearer it was that people didn't really want to gift one specific product. They wanted to send something of value and let the other person decide. So we added gift cards, first in store and then digital. The research had shown the demand, and digital gift card sales jumped once they went live. I bought them myself, because sending someone a $50 gift card so they could pick what they wanted, and have it the next day, was much easier than putting together a box of food for them.
Recipients want to choose
The research points the same way. In a small Tremendous survey this year, people who receive rewards ranked the freedom to spend them anywhere as a top priority [1]. Tremendous and Visa also report that about two-thirds of Gen Z and millennial gift card purchases now happen online [2]. So the shifts we saw, from picking the product to letting the recipient pick, and from the store to online, are happening well beyond one brand.
For a brand, that makes gift cards more than a revenue line. If more of your holiday sales are going to gift cards, that may be a sign your gift lineup doesn't match how people want to give. And what recipients choose when they redeem shows you what the givers couldn't have guessed. That's useful input for next year's bundles, gift guides, and recommendations.
The recipient's first week deserves as much attention as the giver's checkout
Deloitte's 2026 holiday survey found that shoppers plan to buy an average of eight gifts this season [3]. Some of those will reach people meeting your brand for the first time, and some will reach longtime fans. Either way, the recipient is your second customer.
It's easy to treat a delivered gift or a redeemed gift card as a closed sale. For the recipient, it may be their first experience with your brand. What they learn about the product, the reviews they read, and the people they share it with will shape what they think of you after the holidays are over. And if they do come back to buy, the timing of their next purchase matters. I walked through that timing in Your Holiday Buyers Tried the Product. Here's How to Earn the Second Purchase.
So give them a way in. A card or QR code in the box can invite the recipient to register what they received, get tips on using it, and join your program. When someone redeems a gift card, offer them membership with a welcome that helps them enjoy what they picked, like recipes, care tips, or early access to what's next. I made the case for welcoming people with something other than a discount in Your 20% Code Is the Most Expensive Thing You'll Buy This Q4. And if the giver wants to, let them introduce the recipient, so you can thank the giver and get to know the person they chose your brand for.
That gift checkbox taught us to let the recipient choose. This season, give them a way to tell you who they are, too.
Learn how TrueLoyal helps consumer brands turn gift recipients into members with a relationship of their own.
Sources















