Where to Put Experiential Rewards This Holiday

Half of the U.S. holiday shoppers in Deloitte's late-summer survey of 4,000 consumers plan to give someone an experience this year, up from 39% in 2024 [1]. So should your holiday discount codes become experiences too? Read one line further and 79% of those experience givers still plan to pair the experience with something physical. And gifting data says little about what members want from a brand. Ask what people want from a loyalty program, the points and perks a brand gives its repeat buyers, and money off still comes first. So keep the everyday savings, and when a member hits a milestone this season, test a small experience against the bigger code you'd normally send.
Members still rank discounts first in a loyalty program
Forrester's 2025 survey of U.S. online adults found that 75% call instant discounts important in a loyalty program, and 70% say the same about points [2]. Over half also named better customer service and special status, which matter, but rank below money off. Pull member savings to pay for experiences and you take away the benefit people rank highest.
The case for experiences comes from a 2026 Journal of Retailing paper that compared them with merchandise in four lab studies and two field studies [3]. People who earned an experience talked about the brand more, stayed more loyal, redeemed more, and spent more than people who earned a material reward. Even a small experience did about as well as a large material one. Nobody in those studies was offered a discount, so only your own test can show how an experience does against a 25% code.
Put the experience where your bigger milestone code would go
Say you run loyalty for a granola brand. Members get 10% off every order on your site, and at each milestone you send a 25% code that isn't in the program terms. A milestone is a moment your program already marks, like a member's first anniversary or the day they reach a higher level of membership with better perks, which programs call a tier. If your tiers run on spend or points, holiday orders will push more members over the line than usual this month, so more of those codes are about to go out. Each one is just a bigger version of the savings members already get.
There are three reasons to start there. You already pay for a reward at that moment, so the experience replaces a cost instead of adding one. The member just hit a tier or an anniversary, and a reward that shows up right then feels like the brand noticed. And milestones arrive one member at a time, so you can assign each member to a test group on the day they qualify.
In a 2007 study of one convenience store chain's program, the heaviest buyers claimed the most rewards and kept buying exactly as before [4]. The light and moderate buyers bought more over time and stayed. It's one older study in one category, so read your own results by buyer type.
What experiences can a snack or beauty brand offer?
Start with the people who make the product, because that's access members rarely get any other way. e.l.f. Cosmetics builds that access into the top tier of its Beauty Squad program [5]. Members with 2,000 or more points get new products free before launch, chances to take part in product development, and a session with a personal beauty advisor.
For the granola brand, that could be a seat on next year's tasting panel. Members who claim one get three flavors in development by mail, in the small batches a product team already makes for consumer testing. Then they join a 30-minute video tasting with the person who created them, on an evening in late January or February, and their votes help pick which flavor goes into production. Cap each session at the number your developer can really talk with, maybe 25, and add evenings if seats fill.
Then work out the cost. A code costs you only when a member uses it, and part of what it discounts are orders that would have happened anyway. The panel costs samples, shipping, and staff time for every member who claims a seat, whether they show up or not. So budget against what the 25% code actually cost you last holiday season, counting only the orders where members used it and the margin you gave up on each. Your team runs the tasting and ships the samples, since TrueLoyal® doesn't fulfill experiences for you. A webhook, a message the program sends automatically to your other systems, can alert your fulfillment team each time a member redeems points. A form on the reward can collect the shipping address at the same time.
Test the experience against the bigger code, and count who takes part
Take every member who hits a milestone between now and mid-January and split them at random into three groups. One gets the 25% code, one gets a seat on the panel, and one gets the usual milestone email with nothing extra. That last group is your holdout. Because the groups are random, it gives you a fair estimate of what the other two would have bought anyway. And since the code was never promised, nobody loses a benefit they counted on. How to Reward Loyal Customers Without Training Them to Wait for a Code walks through a similar test and shows how to tag a holdout group in TrueLoyal.
Before you look at sales, count who claimed a seat and who showed up or voted. A code doesn't need this step, because an unused code costs nothing. If only a handful took part, the sales numbers measure an offer few people used, so ask a few who passed why before you drop the idea.
Then follow each member for 90 days from their own milestone date, or one full buying cycle if your product is bought less often. Compare repeat purchase rate, meaning the share in each group who came back and bought, then the money each group left you after product costs and the cost of what was redeemed. If your product sells mainly through grocery stores, test on members whose purchases you can see, like those who order on your site or send in receipts. If each group would only reach a few hundred members, set a longer enrollment window before you start, because a test that small often comes back too close to call. How to Prove Your Loyalty Program Is Working covers how to read the results.
Most of Deloitte's experience givers still want something to unwrap with the experience they give. Your granola members can get a version of that pairing, 10% off every order plus a tasting panel seat at their milestone. If the panel group leaves you more money than the code group, you'll know by spring whether to offer it at more milestones in 2027.
Book a demo to see how to set up a milestone experience reward and a tagged holdout group to test it against your bigger code.
Sources
- Deloitte, 2026 Holiday Retail Survey (4,000 U.S. consumers, fielded August 26 to September 10, 2026). deloitte.com
- Forrester, "Consumers Want Financial And Experiential Rewards From Loyalty Programs," data from Forrester's Retail Topic Insights 2 Survey, 2025 (U.S. online adults), updated March 10, 2026. forrester.com
- Ayalla A. Ruvio, Farnoosh Khodakarami, Forrest V. Morgeson, and Clay M. Voorhees, "When rewards connect to the self, Unlocking customer engagement through experiential rewards," Journal of Retailing 102(1), 5 to 23, 2026. ideas.repec.org
- Yuping Liu, "The Long-Term Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Purchase Behavior and Loyalty," Journal of Marketing 71(4), 19 to 35, 2007. yupingliu.com
- e.l.f. Cosmetics, Beauty Squad program page (tiers and perks). elfcosmetics.com
Written by the TrueLoyal® Editorial Team















