< Back to Blog

How to Reward Loyal Customers Without Training Them to Wait for a Code

An empty detergent jug stands upside down in the corner of a washer to drain the last drops

Client Testimonials

See what our clients have to say.

The Simple Solutions community has become a resource across our entire marketing department, as it helps us solve a variety of our business challenges. Led to +16% Increase in Consumption, +8%x Increase in Net Promoter Score, and 52K+x Pieces of User-Generated Content.
Photo of Woman
Brand Manager
Arm & Hammer
The Hero Skin Squad is actively sharing their positive experiences with our products, participating in product development, and helping us spread the word about our new launches. Hero Cosmetics has increased Conversions by +21% in 100 Days with Sampling and Reviews
Photo of Woman
Amy Calhoun Robb
VP of Marketing | Hero Cosmetics
The loyalty program helped us create stronger customer engagement and we have seen the average order value increase by 25.29%
Photo of Woman
Pia Shah
Marketing Analyst | Stride Rite
The structure which TrueLoyal proposed was backed by sound data analysis. I was amazed to see the insights we got. Our customers are now engaged better with our brand. I am more than satisfied with the program.
Photo of Woman
Anabel Peralta
E-commerce Manager | Kid's Warehouse
We were able to capitalize on the holiday season wave with TrueLoyal's loyalty platform. Not only can TrueLoyal help reap benefits, but also sustain such growth. Our repeat purchase revenue increased by 12.45% over and above our holiday season high.
Photo of Woman
Shelbi Johnson
Marketing Manager | Coolhorse
The results from the rewards program are encouraging; in just 6 months after launching the rewards program our customer retention rate has increased by 14X.
Photo of Woman
Anthony Scott
Director of Digital Operations | KBS Research
TrueLoyal's data sciences team helped me to optimize the structure of our program. Within just three months after the launch, we witnessed an impressive 26.72% improvement in customer retention and a 23.39% increase in repeat purchase revenue.
Photo of Woman
Brittany Boykow
Director of E-Commerce | LAFCO
Great service with extremely professional customer support. Very happy with the response time from these guys! Would recommend giving them a try.
Photo of Woman
Sam Gastro
CEO | MyGiftCardSupply
TrueLoyal identified potential areas to boost the revenues and suggested strategies to achieve it. I loved their methodical approach to achieve our business objectives.
Photo of Woman
Natalie Novak-Bauss
Owner | KPS Essentials
We wanted to unlock the true potential of our growing customer base. Our first goal was to deliver a seamless customer experience, and we love the strategic consultation offered by TrueLoyal throughout this journey.
Photo of Woman
Annette Berg
Director of Customer Experience | Defenage
We intuitively know that loyalty reward programs help increase repeat sales. The A/B testing helped quantify the impact.
Photo of Woman
Fabricio Sant’Anna
Marketing Manager | Nature’s Fusions

See What TrueLoyal Can Do For Your
Business

Schedule a demo and we'll show your Loyalty ROI in 45 minutes or less.

Back to Blog

How to Reward Loyal Customers Without Training Them to Wait for a Code

An empty detergent jug stands upside down in the corner of a washer to drain the last drops

This fall, BCG surveyed 10,220 shoppers in 10 countries ahead of the year-end sales, and 76% of the people planning to shop said they hold back purchases at least sometimes [1]. BCG found the same 76% in its 2025 study, so the habit isn't fading [1]. The best members of your loyalty program likely shop those same sales. They hear from you more than anyone else does, so your sale calendar is easy for them to learn, and some of them start holding orders until the next discount code shows up. So if you want to reward loyal customers without paying for orders they'd have placed anyway, start by finding out whether your best members are waiting. If they are, give them a better reason to buy than the next code.

Your best members learn your sale calendar first

They get every code you send, and they buy often enough to spot the pattern. Think of a commuter who learns which train runs half empty and catches that one every day. A member who buys your coffee or snacks on a schedule does the same with your codes. And when they time each order to the next code, they still buy from you as often as before, but now every one of those orders comes with a discount you didn't have to give.

NielsenIQ's 2025 guide to pricing and promotion says nearly half of all promotional sales would have happened without the promotion, though the guide doesn't say how it measured that [2]. If that holds for your brand, close to half the discount you give on a promotion pays for orders that were coming anyway. We covered that margin problem in Your 20% Code Is the Most Expensive Thing You'll Buy This Q4. Bain looked at 2024 and 2025 purchases at grocery and general merchandise retailers from shoppers who use a receipt rewards app, where people scan store receipts to earn points. On average, 42% of returning customers who used an offer also used another offer on their next purchase [3]. That doesn't prove they were waiting, but it's the behavior to look for in your own members.

How can you tell if members are waiting for a code?

You can check for three signs in the order history of your top 10% of members by spend over the last 12 months. Use the order history from your site or, if you use receipt scanning, the receipts members submit. If most of your sales happen in grocery stores with no code attached, run these checks on the members you can identify. Lean on the first and third signs, since those two don't depend on code data.

  1. The time between their orders stretches in the four weeks before a known sale and snaps back right after.
  2. The share of their orders that carry a code climbs quarter by quarter while their total spend stays flat.
  3. Their revenue bunches into sale weeks. If, say, 20% of the weeks bring in 45% of their revenue, the sale may be setting their schedule.

Seasonal swings and stocking up can look like waiting too, so none of these proves it on its own. When two or three show up together in the same group, that's a good reason to run the test below, with a holdout group you leave alone to compare against, before you plan next year's promotions.

What should you reward loyal customers with instead?

Give them a privilege, meaning access they can't get any other way. If your brand is sold in stores, retailers also run their own shelf price cuts on a calendar you don't control. So a member reward that only matches a shelf discount gives your best members nothing new.

Keep any everyday member savings in place, like a standing member price, since pulling them all at once reads as a cut, and add the privilege on top.

Tiers can help too. A tier is a level members reach by earning points or by spending, and if your tiers reset each period, dropping a tier at the end of the period feels like losing status. Holding on to the tier gives members a reason to keep buying between sales.

Early access to a sale is still a discount, just with an earlier start time. So look for something a code can't buy, like a new flavor members try before it reaches stores or a limited run your brand already makes. Check the cost per member too, because a privilege only pays off if it costs less than the code it replaces.

A note on a member's anniversary that names how long they've bought from you costs little to send. Keep it unannounced, so it doesn't become one more thing to wait for.

In a study published in 2021, researchers who followed a large U.S. home improvement retailer's program for two years and more than 10,000 customers found that joining didn't change how much the biggest spenders bought [4]. For the customers most likely to switch to a competitor, spending rose by close to 50%. It's one retailer, so treat it as a pattern to test in your own data. The biggest spenders were buying regardless, and more savings for them is money you don't get back, which is the point we made in Your Best Customers Need the Least. Joining moved spending for the customers most likely to switch to a competitor, so that's where bigger offers have the best chance of paying off, while your best members get the privileges.

Pull the code back from a small group first

Take the code away from a few best members and give them the privilege the same day. Members notice what they lose, so a code that disappears with nothing in its place feels like the brand took something back.

  1. Take a sample of your top 10%, split it into two groups, and leave one group on the normal promo emails as your holdout.
  2. For the other group, swap the code for a privilege tied to their history with you.
  3. After eight weeks, compare each group's repeat purchase rate, which is the share of members who bought again, and its net spend. Net spend here is what members paid after any code discount, minus the cost of any privilege they got. Then keep the holdout running through the next sale to see whether the difference lasts.

In TrueLoyal, you can filter members by tier and other member attributes, and run a campaign for a member segment, with a start and end date, that uses Enable Special Reward as its action. Pick the holdout members yourself and tag them with the bulk Add Tags action on the Members page before the campaign starts. Then use reward rules (Manage Rules on the reward), which can limit who sees a reward by tag, tier, or member attribute, to hide that reward from members carrying your holdout tag. How to Prove Your Loyalty Program Is Working walks through how to read the results.

With a small program, run the test longer so both groups are big enough to compare. If you sell mostly through grocery and use receipt scanning, count the receipts members submit in both groups too, so a member who moved their buying to the shelf still shows up. If the privilege group's repeat purchase rate and net spend hold level with the holdout through the next sale, the code wasn't buying extra orders from those members. You can keep the privilege for the members in that group and stop giving them a code to wait for.

Book a demo to see how to set up a special reward for a segment of your best members and tag a holdout group to compare against.

Written by the TrueLoyal® Editorial Team

Sources

  1. BCG, sixth annual Year-End Sales Events Consumer Study (10,220 consumers aged 18 to 75 in 10 markets, fieldwork September 2026), published November 2026. bcg.com
  2. NielsenIQ, "The Ultimate Guide to Pricing & Promotion" (updated June 2025), p. 25. nielseniq.com
  3. Bain & Company with Fetch, "Beyond Sales Lift, How Rewards Build Valuable Customers" (Fetch Rewards transaction data from 73 CPG brands and 19 grocery and general merchandise retailers, Q2 2024 to Q4 2025, with the 42% figure covering the retailers), June 2026. bain.com
  4. Brett Hollenbeck and Wayne Taylor, "How to Make Your Loyalty Program Pay Off," Harvard Business Review, October 2021. hbr.org. Retailer type from UCLA Anderson Review, "How Loyalty Programs Might Become More Profitable," March 2022. anderson-review.ucla.edu
See It In Practice

Ready to build loyalty that actually earns behavior change? See how TrueLoyal can help.

Schedule a Demo

See What TrueLoyal Can Do For Your Business

Schedule a demo and we'll show your Loyalty ROI in 45 minutes or less.

Close
Schedule a Demo