< Back to Blog

Surviving Cyber Week Means Reading the Holiday Returns

Client Testimonials

See what our clients have to say.

The Simple Solutions community has become a resource across our entire marketing department, as it helps us solve a variety of our business challenges. Led to +16% Increase in Consumption, +8%x Increase in Net Promoter Score, and 52K+x Pieces of User-Generated Content.
Photo of Woman
Brand Manager
Arm & Hammer
The Hero Skin Squad is actively sharing their positive experiences with our products, participating in product development, and helping us spread the word about our new launches. Hero Cosmetics has increased Conversions by +21% in 100 Days with Sampling and Reviews
Photo of Woman
Amy Calhoun Robb
VP of Marketing | Hero Cosmetics
The loyalty program helped us create stronger customer engagement and we have seen the average order value increase by 25.29%
Photo of Woman
Pia Shah
Marketing Analyst | Stride Rite
The structure which TrueLoyal proposed was backed by sound data analysis. I was amazed to see the insights we got. Our customers are now engaged better with our brand. I am more than satisfied with the program.
Photo of Woman
Anabel Peralta
E-commerce Manager | Kid's Warehouse
We were able to capitalize on the holiday season wave with TrueLoyal's loyalty platform. Not only can TrueLoyal help reap benefits, but also sustain such growth. Our repeat purchase revenue increased by 12.45% over and above our holiday season high.
Photo of Woman
Shelbi Johnson
Marketing Manager | Coolhorse
The results from the rewards program are encouraging; in just 6 months after launching the rewards program our customer retention rate has increased by 14X.
Photo of Woman
Anthony Scott
Director of Digital Operations | KBS Research
TrueLoyal's data sciences team helped me to optimize the structure of our program. Within just three months after the launch, we witnessed an impressive 26.72% improvement in customer retention and a 23.39% increase in repeat purchase revenue.
Photo of Woman
Brittany Boykow
Director of E-Commerce | LAFCO
Great service with extremely professional customer support. Very happy with the response time from these guys! Would recommend giving them a try.
Photo of Woman
Sam Gastro
CEO | MyGiftCardSupply
TrueLoyal identified potential areas to boost the revenues and suggested strategies to achieve it. I loved their methodical approach to achieve our business objectives.
Photo of Woman
Natalie Novak-Bauss
Owner | KPS Essentials
We wanted to unlock the true potential of our growing customer base. Our first goal was to deliver a seamless customer experience, and we love the strategic consultation offered by TrueLoyal throughout this journey.
Photo of Woman
Annette Berg
Director of Customer Experience | Defenage
We intuitively know that loyalty reward programs help increase repeat sales. The A/B testing helped quantify the impact.
Photo of Woman
Fabricio Sant’Anna
Marketing Manager | Nature’s Fusions

See What TrueLoyal Can Do For Your
Business

Schedule a demo and we'll show your Loyalty ROI in 45 minutes or less.

Back to Blog

Surviving Cyber Week Means Reading the Holiday Returns

Adobe expects U.S. shoppers to spend $47.5 billion online over Cyber Week this year, the five days from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday on November 30 [1]. On December 1, your loyalty dashboard will show its own spike in points issued, tier upgrades, and new members, all of it earned on orders that can still come back. And holiday returns keep coming in right through the week after Christmas.

That forecast, 7.4% above last year's Cyber Week, covers all U.S. online shopping, so your week may run hotter or cooler. The biggest week of the year produces its numbers in five days, and the returns that change them take weeks. So the job for Cyber Week and the ten days after it is to keep the program steady while returns come in, and to judge new customers by whether they buy again.

What should a loyalty team watch during Cyber Week?

Watch whether points post correctly, and build a list of the members a return could move. The first part is a daily check that points land on orders and that support isn't fielding questions about balances that look wrong.

For the list, pull every member who moved up a tier, meaning the status level members earn by buying, on a single Cyber Week order. Then pull the members whose first order with you came that week. One returned order can drop the first group back down, and a returned first order can leave a new member with nothing they kept. Tag both groups and leave them out of any December count of new loyal members.

Why do Cyber Week numbers look better on December 1 than in January?

On December 1, Cyber Week returns are only starting. In a 2025 survey of 358 ecommerce leaders at U.S. retailers with more than $500 million in revenue, the National Retail Federation and Happy Returns found that retailers expected to see 17% of their holiday sales come back [2]. They planned on roughly one holiday dollar in six going back, and your rate may differ.

The tail runs long, too. Adobe counted the 2025 holiday season as November 1 through December 31, and one in every seven returns it tracked came between December 26 and December 31 [3]. That's the whole season, gifts included, but it shows the last week of the year is still busy with returns. So the December 1 number is gross, meaning before returns, and it keeps shrinking until the season's returns are in.

A shopper who joins during the biggest sale of the year looks like a great member on day one, and comparing members with non-members that week mostly tells you who joins during a sale. The better test is the second purchase, which Your Holiday Buyers Tried the Product. Here's How to Earn the Second Purchase. walks through. For the Cyber Week group, the number worth reporting is how many are still buying in February, after their returns have cleared.

What happens to points and tiers when a Cyber Week order comes back?

The points that order earned should come off the member's balance, and any tier the order earned should be checked again. The member should also hear about it from you before they notice it on their own.

That last step shapes how the return feels to the member. In the same NRF and Happy Returns research, 71% of shoppers who had returned an online purchase in the past year said a poor returns experience made them less likely to shop with that retailer again [2]. A balance that drops with no explanation is a poor returns experience, and so is a tier badge that vanishes overnight. Write the sentence your support team will use, and the note the member will see, before the first return lands. Decide now, too, what happens when a member has already spent the points from an order they later send back.

In TrueLoyal®, when your store or order system sends a return, the platform takes back the points that order earned, in full or for only the items that came back. If your tiers are earned over a set period or a rolling window, a return that lowers a member's qualifying points or spend triggers a fresh look at their tier. TrueLoyal can also send a webhook, an automatic alert from one system to another, when points are deducted or a tier drops. That lets your email tool skip the tier welcome for someone who just moved back down. And you can hold purchase points as pending until an approval date you set, so points on a Cyber Week order wait out the return window.

What should you not do in the ten days after Cyber Monday?

Don't change how the program earns or rewards while returns are still coming in. Your site may already be under a holiday code freeze, but point values, tier rules, and promotions often sit with marketing, outside it. Changes made now land on numbers that are still moving, and later you can't tell which change did what.

Don't launch a second points promotion to extend the rush, since it piles points on orders that haven't settled. Don't change point values or tier thresholds while members are still working out what they just earned. Don't congratulate anyone on a tier earned with a Cyber Week order until that order's return window has closed. And don't report the spike as program lift. Showing what the program added takes a holdout group, members kept out of an offer for comparison, which How to Prove Your Loyalty Program Is Working explains. Write down the December 1 numbers, label them gross, and put a January date on the calendar to read them again.

The January read also sets up next year. It shows which new members kept what they bought, and it gives you your own return rate for setting approval dates and tier rules before the next Cyber Week. If the Cyber Week group isn't tagged as its own group yet, Five Questions to Ask Your Retention Team Before Cyber Week covers how to set that up.

So when the December 1 dashboard shows points, upgrades, and new members at record highs, enjoy it for a day. Then treat it as the first draft of a number you'll finish in January.

Book a demo to see how TrueLoyal adjusts points and tiers when orders come back, so your January numbers match what members kept.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Cyber Week?

Cyber Week is the five days from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday, as Adobe defines it [1]. In 2026 it runs from November 26 through November 30.

How long do holiday returns keep coming in?

They keep coming in past Christmas. Adobe found that one in seven returns it tracked in the 2025 holiday season came between December 26 and December 31 [3], so plan to read Cyber Week loyalty results in January.

Should a returned order take back loyalty points?

Yes. Take back points in proportion to what came back, and tell the member in plain words when it happens.

How do you measure Cyber Week loyalty results?

Record the December 1 numbers as gross, read them again in January, and judge new members on whether they buy a second time.

Sources

  1. Adobe, "U.S. Holiday Shopping Season to Hit Record $275.1 Billion Online, Rising 6.7% YoY" (September 28, 2026). Forecast for November 1 to December 31, 2026, including Cyber Week and Cyber Monday, based on Adobe Analytics data from online sales at U.S. retail sites. news.adobe.com
  2. National Retail Federation and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape (October 15, 2025). Surveys from summer 2025 of 358 ecommerce professionals at U.S. retailers with more than $500 million in revenue and 2,006 consumers who had returned at least one online purchase in the past 12 months. nrf.com
  3. Adobe, "Holiday Shopping Season Drove a Record $257.8 Billion Online with Consumers Embracing Generative AI Tools" (January 7, 2026). 2025 holiday season, November 1 to December 31, based on Adobe Analytics data from online sales at U.S. retail sites. news.adobe.com
See It In Practice

Ready to build loyalty that actually earns behavior change? See how TrueLoyal can help.

Schedule a Demo

See What TrueLoyal Can Do For Your Business

Schedule a demo and we'll show your Loyalty ROI in 45 minutes or less.

Close
Schedule a Demo